I’ve been dreaming of space since I was a little kid. I’m an avid science fiction fan, and like most kids of my generation I grew up immersed in Star Wars and the attendant fantasies of galactic exploration. Given this it may be a surprise to hear that I am not a fan of the recently announced Mars initiatives. I recognize to some extent the power of a dream and the positive effects the moon landings had on our culture. I don’t think you can pull the same trick twice though. While landing men on Mars would be an amazing achievement, it’s not going to have the same impact that the original moon landings did. Our interests would be better served continuing to use robotic missions to explore the solar system.
I do agree with the need to retire the shuttle fleet and move to a new launch vehicle however, and getting a permanent colony started on the moon is a fantastic idea. Not as a stepping stone to Mars mind you, but to the asteroid belt, where (supposedly) the real treasure is to be found.
Like most critics of the Bush Junta I am suscpicious that this is all really just about military expansion though. Who else can get launch vehicles onto the moon and start a moon base? Who could challenge the authority of a power that could drop an asteroid on you from space with absolute impunity, and knock your communications system out of the sky should you cross us? I’m sure from the Neocon perspective this sort of move makes perfect sense. I suspect like with the WMD/al qaeda = iraq misconceptions the American public holds, this will remain almost completely off everyone’s radar until its become a fait accompli. Assuming my cynical paranoia pans out that is, and assuming congress agrees to fund this, which at this point actually seems fairly unlikely.